Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Patents Transportation Software Hardware Technology

Tesla Files Patent For Automatic Turn Signals (cnet.com) 161

Tesla has filed a patent for automatic turn signals. The filing details a system that uses Autopilot sensors to determine when drivers are going to make a turn and signal automatically. CNET reports: Tesla wants its vehicles to signal automatically without the driver needing to go through the agony that is lifting their finger and moving it up or down by several inches. The way that Tesla envisions it working is that the car detects the driver's intent to change lanes or make a turn by using the Autopilot hardware at its disposal, it then works to sense if there are other vehicles nearby and if it detects them, it puts the signal on for the driver. If it works, it will be brilliant but given the fact that Tesla has remained adamant that it doesn't need driver monitoring systems for Autopilot, it seems questionable that the vehicle would be able to detect a driver's intent to turn based solely on external observation.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Tesla Files Patent For Automatic Turn Signals

Comments Filter:
  • by OzPeter ( 195038 ) on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:37PM (#57228212)

    The point of turn signals is not to engage when the turn is in progress, but to indicate the intent of a turn. Doing it when the drive is pulling on the wheel to make the turn will go against the road rules of many locales.

    Unless of course Tesla has developed a telepathic module for their cars. In which case I take back what I said.

    • by Nkwe ( 604125 ) on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:52PM (#57228298)

      The point of turn signals is not to engage when the turn is in progress, but to indicate the intent of a turn. Doing it when the drive is pulling on the wheel to make the turn will go against the road rules of many locales.

      In the addition, turn signals are supposed to be used whether *or not* there are other cars around. Technically some jurisdictions don't require signaling if there are no other vehicles around, but good driving practices suggest always signaling because 1) you might be wrong about no other vehicles being around (and if you haven't seen the other vehicle that is actually there, your signaling might just give the other driver enough warning that you are about to encroach on their space), and 2) always signaling builds a good habit and reduces one piece of driving cognitive load. If your brain isn't thinking about "do I have to single at this time" it has more cycles to think about other driving safety related issues.

      • by djinn6 ( 1868030 )
        I'd go even further and say signaling is especially important when you think there are no other cars around. Chances are, they're hiding in your blind spot.
      • by Misagon ( 1135 ) on Thursday August 30, 2018 @07:25PM (#57228478)

        Turn signals are not interpreted only by other motorists on the road but also by pedestrians.
        This is very useful on parking lots, for instance.

      • by mikael ( 484 )

        That drives me nuts when trying to cross the road as a pedestrian. Some drivers just don't bother indicating whether they are going straight on or turning left when they pass an intersection. So they make the turn without indicating.

      • by rnturn ( 11092 )
        Remember the black woman who was killed when leaving a Texas college campus after a job interview? Pulled over for not signaling a lane change even though there was nobody around except the cop driving a block behind her.
    • by Anonymous Coward

      I leave my turn signals on, never know when I'm gonna turn turn turn

    • Unless of course Tesla has developed a telepathic module for their cars. In which case I take back what I said.

      I haven't read the patent but telepathy probably isn't necessary. Humans leave a lot of subconscious clues about their intents and, if you have the right sensors, in many cases, you can detect what they are about to do before they have consciously decided to do it. My favorite example of this is FMCW Lidar and pedestrians at a crosswalk. You can literally see subtle doppler shifts in how they are distributing their weight well before they've taken a step and probably before they've even consciously decid

      • According to my local rules of the road, if you want to take a freeway exit, you have to start signalling 1000 ft before the exit. What kind of unconscious action would you expect to be able to pick up at that distance ?

        • by q_e_t ( 5104099 )

          The best I can suggest is that if you make a particular trip often (e.g. your commute) it could assume that you are going to do it. But ideally you'd want it to say "Dave, I suggest you signal turning off the highway now".

          Even with GPS I would not suggest it automatically going as far as signalling. Sometimes there is only part of a journey I need the GPS for, but it will be on for all of it as I don't want to stop part way to turn it on. But, say, returning home I might decide to stop at the grocery store

          • The problem with these kinds of automatic things is that I want to work flawlessly, or I'd rather do it all myself. Having to turn off automatic signalling lights that come on at the wrong moment is much more annoying than having to turn them on at the right times.

            Voice reminders at the wrong time are also annoying and distracting.

    • How about using informatiom from navigation software?

      How difficult is to connect green wire from Waze to the white wire of the turning light?

      At first I though they are going to patent that ine which would be also ridiculous

  • the agony that is lifting their finger and moving it up or down by several inches.

    Several inches? Is that what it takes on a Tesla? On all my cars, and my parents cars, going back nearly forty years of driving, the turn signal only takes (or took) a half and inch or so – up or down – to activate.
    OTOH, getting drivers – Tesla or otherwise – to put down their phone or coffee to signal a turn probably is asking a lot.
    In other news I predict a fresh rash of accidents as people pull out in front of a Tesla that has its turn signal on.

  • The way that Tesla envisions it working is that the car detects the driver's intent to change lanes or make a turn by using the Autopilot hardware at its disposal, it then works to sense if there are other vehicles nearby and if it detects them, it puts the signal on for the driver.

    Except the law requires you to signal when turning even if no other cars are nearby in many states. Similarly for lane changes. This needs to be done ahead of time, say 100 feet for example. So it would have to be fairly floolproof or it could wind up backfiring if it failed and tickets were issued or an accident happened. Sometimes when a company files patents like this it is simply and attempt to create a wall of IP such that others find it difficult to compete or sometimes it's simply to pad a portf

  • by Anonymous Coward

    Presumably if the car knows where my destination is and the route I intend to take, it can use the turn signals appropriately without my input - no sophisticated body-language-reading AI required.

  • Decent drivers give a fairly early indication of a turn with small movements of the steering wheel (invisible from outside the car), but plenty of not-so-good drivers will turn the steering wheel left before starting the intended right turn. And you wait till it's clear you have turned to turn on the turn signal that's maybe avoiding a ticket with no improvement in safety. Unless this is really meant for slow city traffic and pedestrians in which case...ok...maybe.

  • Have autopilot execute the turn, but only after the turn signal has been activated (by the driver) an appropriate amount of time.

    That is, make it so that the cars make turns that have been properly signalled.

    It reduces driver workload and enforces safe driving habits.

  • seems unsafe!

  • Interesting that they could get.a patent for this. So all other automated cars for ever more will have an excuse not to signal, because Tesla owns the patent?
  • by erp_consultant ( 2614861 ) on Thursday August 30, 2018 @07:51PM (#57228622)

    How about a patent to automatically turn OFF the turn signal that has been left on for the past 5 miles...and the car is still in the same lane? You know the type of driver I'm talking about. The one in the left lane, 10 MPH below the speed limit, driving the late 90s or early 00s Cadillac. Yeah...the one with the tuft of blue hair just barely above the dashboard. On the way to the bingo or shuffle board tournament.

    Yes, the dreaded Snow Bird. The only thing worse than no signal is the perpetual signal. You have no idea what their true intention is. All you know is that you need to get the heck away from them. NOW.

    • Man, you've got issues. Ranting in public about this isn't healthy.
    • by bozzy ( 992580 )
      My '91 Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme automatically beeped at you when you left the turn signal on too long. Between that and the huge digital speedometer it was clear this car was designed for the market you're talking about.
  • While this seems a little silly on the surface,
    I've noticed since moving to LA that almost nobody uses their turning signals here. It's gotten much worse over the past 7 years.

    I'll take any additional help that the car can give these idiots, but I'm concerned that common adoption of features like this will make people even less likely to signal in advance of doing something stupid.

    • What you need is an Augmented Reality app that will superimpose turn signals on any cars it perceives as turning? Maybe some AI that will even watch for the drivers eyeing their blind spot before turning? Way more likely to work than hoping everyone in LA starts driving a Tesla.

  • Not sure if patentable but if so Tesla should make available for free to others. Volvo first to widely deploy cross chest seat belt but did not patent and allowed others to use since safety in the interests of advancement of automobiles adoption. A shared safety pact should be adopted by the industry for such features as they are for others.
  • I think I'd like a feature like this if it at least FORCES the signals to come on as someone is starting to turn, in case they were otherwise going to skip using them at all.

    As others said, half of the purpose of a turn signal is to indicate you'd like to turn ... hoping other drivers will cut you some slack and open up a space for you to begin doing it. Automatic signals will be totally useless for this.

    So you wouldn't want to get rid of the signal lever here, IMO. But you might want the automatic functi

  • Some racing video games had this feature where when you changed lanes, the car would start to signal in that direction. There is a game on the Google Play store right now that does this.

    Or is prior art negated because it is virtual and doesn't send the actual CANBUS command to trigger the turn signal?

    P A T E N T S

    -dk

    • Some racing video games had this feature where when you changed lanes, the car would start to signal in that direction. There is a game on the Google Play store right now that does this.

      Or is prior art negated because it is virtual and doesn't send the actual CANBUS command to trigger the turn signal?

      It's only prior art if it covers every element of the claim. If the video game just did "player turns steering wheel -> turn on signal", then it would only be prior art if that's all that's in a claim in Tesla's patent application. I looked at the patent application very briefly, and Claim 1 requires four different data sources, two of which are used to determine if there's another vehicle nearby.

  • I'm sure they will use recurring trips / timing to calculate likely destination.

    Home -> School
    School -> Work
    Work -> Shop | Work -> Home
    [Shop -> Home]

  • Donate a license to use this tech to BMW users.
    They need it bad!

  • " If it works, it will be brilliant but given the fact that Tesla has remained adamant that it doesn't need driver monitoring systems for Autopilot,"

    Anyone who thinks Tesla cars are capable of self driving is drinking too much kool aid. The car can manage itself in some limited scenarios but even there it requires an attentive driver to hit the brakes or overrule the car if it does something dangerous. As such it should be a legal requirement that every semi-autonomous vehicles MUST enforce driver attenti

  • signal automatically without the driver needing to go through the agony that is lifting their finger and moving it up or down by several inches

    Oh! So THAT'S why no one ever signals. Didn't realize it was causing them such torment.

  • nice post thanks for sharing interesting information keep on sharing like this and Many students prefer to study in Canada because of its diversity, inclusive education and high standard of living.In addition to high per capital income Read More At https://www.meetuniversity.com... [meetuniversity.com]

Algebraic symbols are used when you do not know what you are talking about. -- Philippe Schnoebelen

Working...