RFID Not Just for Kids 335
dritan writes "News.com is reporting that a theme park in Florida is tagging all members of your group when you enter. The park has kiosks throughout the park that let you find the other members of your group in "real time." The park's web site makes it seem that you will only be able to find members of your group, instead of seeing everyone in the park. Slashdot has previously reported about tagging kids with RFID in order to keep track of them."
sigh... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:sigh... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:sigh... (Score:2)
Re:sigh... (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:sigh... (Score:2)
The English language needs gender neutral singular and possesive pronouns to refer to someone in the third person.
Re:sigh... (Score:4, Informative)
Max
Re:sigh... (Score:4, Informative)
Absolutely. I even used to walk 30 minutes to and from school alone every day when I was 8. No wonder kids get no exercise these days, they're not allowed more than 6 feet from their parents. We used to call that overprotective, now it seems to be the norm. (I can say this now because I am a parent myself.)
Re:sigh... (Score:3, Interesting)
I know everyone hasn't already pointed out how silly your comment is but I can't resist... Any parent with adventurous children learns quickly that the trick is have lose enough control that your kids don"t have the perception of being under your control or observation so the quit trying (as the spy novels say) "lose their tail". But your have to be adept and quick enough to prevent them from committing any felonies or terrorist acts. On top of that I want my kids to have some
Re:sigh... (Score:5, Funny)
"Remember to take all packages and property with you when you leave the boat. Please make sure you also take your children. Because if you don't want them, then we don't want them either... For many of the same reasons."
"Any children left behind at the end of the day become property of Walt Disney World Incorporated. At which time we take them over to the It's A Small World pavilion , staple their feet to the floor and teach them that awful little song in forty-two different languages. I myself used to be the hula-girl"
- Boat operator on the Jungle Safari Cruise at Disney World Magic Kingdom, Spring 1996.
And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:4, Insightful)
This should be good.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:5, Funny)
I agree, some people seem to overhype RFID privacy problems a bit.
There should be no problem with this, simply microwaving the children for a short period should be sufficient to disable the tag.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:5, Funny)
No, no, no... 5 minutes a side under the broiler for browning, then microwave to cook through. The microwave time varies by weight.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2, Funny)
Thats a DMCA violation!
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:5, Insightful)
It's to track kids - never mind that it tracks everyone whether they have kids in tow or not.
But if it finds a few lost kids then great. Who can disagree with that? Unless of course it might substantially lessen a child's safety.
Why? Well the parents will be more inclined to leave a tagged child on his / her own because he / she can be tracked. As a consequence there are more separated children within the park. Even an unsophisticated abducter could just grab a random lone child and make a beeline for the exit - once out the park the RFID is no good. A smarter abductor would remove the RFID tag first. A smarter one yet might use the RFID to find out the where the parents were in order to avoid them before discarding it.
In other words, it's hard to see how an RFID helps that much at all. It will help in your everyday lost child situation, but it instills a false sense of security at the same time.
Perhaps it is better that kids are chaperoned by their parents rather than tracked by chips after all.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2, Insightful)
Lost children is a convenient explanation. I'm sure the park can't actually use the technology to see which bits of the park are most popular, where the best place to put concessions, what ride lengths need shortening to maximize throughput or anything like that. Oh no.
Yes, but all of those sound like a good thing to me as well. Do you actually disagree with those?
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2)
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:3, Funny)
The point here is that 'saving kids' is a convenient excuse for something which is more likely being introduced for commercial reasons. It isn't even a good excuse (and quite possibly dangerous) for reasons I pointed out.
And for that every
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2)
yet...
remember, the future is but an quickly granted patent away.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2)
Besides, they are already studying ways to improve their facilities. And that includes studying which rides are popular and which are not. Do you complain about that as well? Or i
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2)
Re:Why make it so sinister? (Score:3, Insightful)
Because if they aren't lying, it is ok. If they are lying, then everything brought up is acceptable to me so far as well.
If your real objection is being lied to by corporations, your only recourse is to move to your own private island. I hate to be the one to break it to you, but corporations lie all the time, and it isn't illegal (and since corporations have no morals, isn't immoral or unethical either).
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:5, Insightful)
Which means it is no surprise at all to me that the theme park is largely using this for data collection purposes to optimise layouts and rides. As you say "finding lost children" is just the convenient limp excuse to get the system in place. After a while people will just take it for granted.
At the same time - there's really nothing at all wrong with this. In a sense they're just trying to provide the best service possible, and it's their property, so really they can do what they like. You dont want to be RFIDd and tracked? Don't go to that theme park. Nobody is forcing you to go there.
Jedidiah.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:3, Interesting)
Lost children is a convenient explanation. I'm sure the park can't actually use the technology to see which bits of the park are most popular, where the best place to put concessions, what ride lengths need shortening to maximize throughput or anything like that. Oh no.
We wouldn't want them to be able to make the place better now would we!Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:3, Insightful)
Yeah, I don't WANT those lines shortened to maximise throughput. No, please don't put concession stands where they are convenient to get to, I'd much rather they and the bathrooms be as inaccesible as possible. OMFG, they are gathing data on me!!! AAAGHG it's the ultimate evil - a marketer with data on ME!!! The sky is falling!
And please, your abductor scenario is so stupid it's practically a strawman.
Adult A enters park, children BCD enter park.
Tag A is associated with B, C, and D.
Eve
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2, Funny)
Is Apple involved in anyway? If so RFID is then OK : )
-Colin [colingregorypalmer.net]
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2)
While they might say it is to locate lost children (or their parents), i suspect a convenient side issue will be that they will get a very clear picture of what people spend time and money on in their park.
And whether they think there is too much ice in their soda.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:2)
If you care about your children do not expect technology to keep them safe. Not yet anyway. We need to change our mindset. There are some situations where there is no room for error.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:3, Insightful)
This is actually a brilliant move by the RFID providers. This "how can you object?" application will be the first significant exposure many people will have to RFID. Later, when they hear about objectionable applications, they will already be biased by the good that RFID can do.
Re:And now, for your delectation and delight... (Score:3, Insightful)
Since I recently moved, I tried re-registering to vote in the new district. My wife (hardcore Republican) said not to bother because I usually side on the independent and I would be "wasting my vote". Funny thing, when I pass by the political party tents at the local Fair, they all ask if I'm registered to vote. I say, "No". I let them speak their piece about registering to vote, and I'm usually ready to fill out the paperwork they provide as a convienience. W
Marketing Research Tool? (Score:2, Insightful)
and.. (Score:5, Insightful)
They can pin point your location so lets say a little boy and a "older man" magicly end up in the same toilet cubicle..... well then
Could be very useful for this kinda thing
Re:and.. (Score:2)
Oh wait! No don't! Get away! Get aw--OUUUCH!
. . . Hey Mom! Look what I got pierced!
Re:and.. (Score:2)
as for vandalism linking.. cameras are more useful.
and as for following someone.. eyes are much more useful.
Theme parks freak me out.. (Score:5, Insightful)
Sure, there is this nice image of happiness and friendliness.. but it's also obviously fake and false. (Even as a 7-year old at disneyland, I felt it)
At the same time, there are guards and surveillance cameras everywhere, not to mention the rigorous safety measures.
It's like being inside a Soviet propaganda movie or something.
And that was before they started tagging people. I can't say I'm surprized.
Re:Uhh, they don't. (Score:2)
But is it open to abuse? (Score:5, Interesting)
Can the park individually track where you are? probably, but it's their right to do so - you've voluntarily entered their private property after all, and paid for the privilege. Can they track your preferences within the park? probably.
will they store any personal identifiers? there's the rub. if their database links your RFID tag to the visa card number you paid with, THEN we're talking problems, and of course the article doesn't make it clear if this can happen or not...
Re:But is it open to abuse? (Score:2)
At the moment.
Fast forward two years:
As you board your train to work, a member of the trains company's private 'Homeland Security Force' stops you.
"Excuse me sir. The RFID you are carrying does not match your VISA card. Step this way please..."
In two years we'll have National Identity cards in the UK too.
and probably tattoos on our foreheads.
Re:But is it open to abuse? (Score:2)
ah but which church? and will they sell the marketing rights to your choice of psuedo-democratic government/unethical corperation/secret new world order?
tin foil fallout shelters will not protect us should the demeritocracies of the world finally prove capeable of cohesive thought or desicive action.
as a side note, I am aware of the predictions in the book of revelation. Fortunately, I ha
Re:If THIS is not open to abuse, then what is?! (Score:3, Insightful)
if you hate the idea so much, the solution is simple: Don't go to the frigging park!
get it right (Score:4, Insightful)
move on, nothing to see here
Re:get it right (Score:2)
Re:get it right (Score:2)
You must be new here. Welcome to Slashdot, simonharvey!
Re:get it right (Score:5, Funny)
First time I saw RFID and didn't flip out. (Score:2, Interesting)
Nope... I didn't read the article.
The folly of it all! (Score:2, Funny)
Re:The folly of it all! (Score:2, Funny)
Comment removed (Score:5, Insightful)
Before you post: Hands up who has kids! (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Before you post: Hands up who has kids! (Score:2)
My only concern is if a child is abducted, the abductor can just remove the wristband and throw the police off for a while and buy some time.
Re:Before you post: Hands up who has kids! (Score:3, Insightful)
Yeah! Who cares about freedom, saving the life of even just one child trumps all of that stupid stuff. Who needs freedom anyway when our children are being slaughtered in theme parks all across this great country, home of the free, land of the brave?
My only
Re:Before you post: Hands up who has kids! (Score:3, Interesting)
I'd like to see posters in this discussion indicate if they have kids or not. I'm going to guess that those who post "not over my dead body/evil CIA tracking device/civil liberties being eroded by govt." are the single adults who've never lost a small child they are responsible for in a large, crowded public place.
Damn straight. If I ever take my eyes off my kids in public, it's by accident. I don't see why a tag that assists me in doing the exact same thing is evil.
Re:Before you post: Hands up who has kids! (Score:2)
Re:Seems OK (Score:3, Interesting)
I see nothing wrong with this use of RFID tags, as the users of it *want* it to be used for tracking. There's no reason this wouldn't be a 'good' thing if
Re:Seems OK (Score:2)
The problem with RFID tags is that if a large number of the goods we buy have them, then it's easy for someone to put RFID readers out there so that when you pass them, they know what you are currently holding, which will likely lead to targetted advertising as you walk down the streets. I.e., if you are the type of person to buy expensive clothing, don't be suprised if you tend to get extra attention while shopping from the sales people.
I hope the RFID tags survive long enough to make it to the thrif
Re:Seems OK (Score:4, Insightful)
Now how do they correlate that with product information? Or, where do they get the "master data" (name, maker, stats, etc - catalog info) for that product? If it is something in their database already (e.g. a product that they sell), then they might be able to do a match against it. Otherwise, you have some anonymous product in your possession. Oh yeah, and do this all in realtime.
Now assuming they managed to score all that info from someplace. What will they do with it? Most stories about what CRM can do, such as men buying beer between 5 and 6 PM tend to correlate with men buying diapers in the same time frame; hence the store put diapers and beer together and profits went up, are just that; stories. In fact, they don't put the wealth of information they already get from customer cards to very sophisticated use.
Now if I could put a custom RFID tag on my keys and shoes, I could figure out where I put my keys and wallet what my kids did with my left shoe.
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Seems OK (Score:2)
Re:Seems OK (Score:4, Insightful)
This is one of those thigns I'm in two minds about. On the one hand being a private person and somewhat paranoid about quite how much information people can get/keep I have to admit being rather worried about something like this being abused.
However I've been a youth leader on a trip to a theme park this summer, trying to round up the final stragglers about half an hour after the deadline to get back to the coach.
And when we finally found them? They were queueing up for food - which in turn they'd have to finish before being allowed back on the coach. (Terms of hiring)
There was also the point on the same trip where all of the leaders were on the lookout for the trip organiser. Half an hour of searching and I bumped into him by accident by the front gates.
So yeah. On the one hand I don't like the idea of people being able to track me, and i am concerned about the security of such a system making sure that only party members could find people - not stalkers and the like.
TiggsBut on the other hand I've recently been in a position of being unable to track down party members at such a place. And if you've booked a coach for a certain time you have to be able to round everybody up by a set time.
Dude! (Score:2, Funny)
Woah. Gnarly.
Thanks Mouseman.
Goddamnit! (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Goddamnit! (Score:2, Funny)
Just place your RFID tag in your mother-in-law's handbag.
That should do the trick.
Re:Goddamnit! (Score:2, Funny)
UN Black Helicopters (Score:3, Funny)
I hate to sound like an apocalypse nut, but within 15 years it will be capable of one individual (i.e. antichrist) to control/track just about everyone on the planet, including money and food.
Re:UN Black Helicopters (Score:2)
Re:UN Black Helicopters (Score:4, Funny)
Yeah, but once they use their black helicopters to see how much money we all have and take the money, then they'll be able to pay for better police, and then we're in really big trouble.
Is it voluntary? (Score:5, Insightful)
Anyway, unless it's mandatory, it should be okay. It's pretty close to being watched by CC cameras when you wonder around a department store.
Re:Is it voluntary? (Score:4, Insightful)
Let's say you go into the park, pay by credit card, wander round a bit and the system tracks you and your activities. Now if the company in question (lets say Disney) can link the ID to your CC number, and if they retain the data, then they'll be able to tightly market to you later based on what you did at the park.
Hung around a lot in the little kids park? you likely have small children, so we can market kids stuff to you. Sit in the bar all day while the rest of the party wandered round in bliss? well, there's stuff we can market there too.... that's my only worry.
Re:Is it voluntary? (Score:4, Insightful)
So it's cheaper, right? and what happens when the price goes down?
Demand (and volume) go up.
So the marketing may be more relevant, but there'd be a load more of it. The savings certainly wouldn't go to anything as crass as lowering the price of the product or (god forbid) improving it - that's not what marketing is for.
at least, that's one theory
Re:Is it voluntary? (Score:2)
Or are you saying that the consumer is harmed because the company saves some money, but the price of the product does not go down? Are they required to lower their prices?
Re:Is it voluntary? (Score:2, Interesting)
what kind of data have would you have to give and with which information would it be connected?
who would decide which advertisment is the right one for you?
where would the information be stored and for how long?
who would be in control of all of this and what would his objectives be?
Re:Is it voluntary? (Score:3, Insightful)
Why would I have to concern myself with that? Well, to amuse you: I propably wouldn't have to give any kind of data, it would be collected automatically. What data, and connected with what other data? Propably what I bought, when and where. If someone knows that I bought a pair of socks at the local supermarket, big deal.
Irrelevant. At worst, I wou
RFID responsible use (Score:5, Insightful)
1. I know it's being used
2. I'm not required to use it
3. I can turn it off
Re:RFID responsible use (Score:2)
Now, a screwdriver can be used to turn screws, or it can be plunged into someone's head.
An RFID can be plunged into someone's head as well, I presume.
And they wonder.. (Score:2, Funny)
This sounds like an exciting new tool! (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:This sounds like an exciting new tool! (Score:2)
ooh, there's a good point. It significantly lowers the skill level required to be an active stalker. Hooray for technology, making everyone's life easier, even the creepier ones among us.
now, where are my trenchcoat and dark glasses?
Re:This sounds like an exciting new tool! (Score:2)
Hurricanes (Score:2, Funny)
Lunch: $20
Knowing your party landed in Alabama: priceless.
in the workplace (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:in the workplace (Score:5, Insightful)
Son't you mean "when workplaces did start using RFID..."?
Some places have already done so in Europe - to make sure the empolyees don't "forget" to punch out when they leave for lunch, or even worse (at least from the employees point of view) forget to punch back in when they return.
Raises questions? Sure it does - how can you be sure they don't monitor restbreaks and whatnot as well. Makes life simpler? Sure it does - as long as you remember your card.
Mexican Gov't requires RFID implants (Score:2)
http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/july2004/1907 04mythofrfid.htm [prisonplanet.com].
Search the web for it too. There's lots written about it. It's from a month and a half ago or so, so a lot of it has already fallen out of Google News, but it's still mentioned.
Note it's not just an ID card -- it's an implant. If your job required one, would you take it?
Wannadocity.com? (Score:2, Funny)
Just sayin'..
Imagine the fun you could have .... (Score:5, Funny)
Or
Or
Re:Imagine the fun you could have .... (Score:2)
Ski passes (Score:4, Insightful)
Regards,
treefrog
Re:Ski passes (Score:2, Interesting)
I can also see them being very useful for the resort management to analyse patterns of movement on slopes. OK, a lot of it isn't rocket science, but I really hate resorts where all the runs descend into the beginners area - it just seems so unfair on those trying to learn (Are yo
Re:Ski passes (Score:2)
But you wouldn't want the scout leader finding out where you are. That Holy Grail belongs in a museum!
And remember folks... (Score:3, Interesting)
..if you don't like the idea of being tagged and tracked - well, don't go to that park that tag and track you. Problem solved.
Off course, if the US goverment (or any other evil organisation/entity of your choice) started doing this, allowing you to be "found in real time", you might have a reason to scream up about "civil liberties" and whatnot.. but as long as it's private company doing it on their own property you have nothing to say in the matter - except to vote with your dollars and feet. Besides, I like the idea to find the kids when it's time to leave - spendt way to much time tracking down a kid that didn't want to be found because he didn't want to leave one time.
It's a wrist band! (Score:5, Interesting)
Theme parks are all about control anyway. The better ones have good control which results in a good experience. (That is what you pay for.) The poor ones have not thought everything out resulting in problems. (Which is what you don't pay for.)
It's a good feature. Pay cash if you don't want your prefs tracked to your identity.
Technology behind it... (Score:2)
Probably the last one.
I took a look at their website, but couldn't find any hints
Hide and seek (Score:5, Interesting)
Given that both the hunter and the hunted can see each others locations - but only when visiting the booths - then some interesting strategies could come out.
What would be really cool would be if you could tell the park you're doing this and they limit access to the location data to something like 1 minute access every 5 minutes to prevent 'booth squatting'!
Now I'd visit that park.
looking for kids... (Score:5, Insightful)
finding loopholes in this type of system isn't something that you can afford to do after it's been widely put into use.
RFID on kids? (Score:3, Insightful)
I for one... (Score:4, Funny)
Not as bad..... (Score:3, Insightful)
Probably not that big a deal (Score:4, Interesting)
People spend too much time being paranoid of what RFID can be used for in all the wrong ways. If they don't go overboard this isn't a bad idea, because we all hear about the person who had their kid wander off. Imagine if you could just go to a park booth and say hi I'm so and so and my kid just wandered off, they could tell you where the kid was instantly.
Splash Country does this already (Score:5, Informative)
I found it *extremely* useful since I could let my daughter ride the waterslides without worrying about how to find her when it was time for lunch or time to go home. Likewise, she could find me quickly and easily if she needed to. I certainly didn't feel that my privacy was being invaded and I wasn't able to track any other users in the park.
Is there potential for abuse? Of course there is, but it's like any other tool. It can be used for good or evil. In this case, I feel there's no evil intent and it helps prevent lost kids.
Re:hmmm (Score:2)
of course if they hate you and they're deliberately trying to ditch you, then the knife cuts both ways
Re:hmmm (Score:2, Funny)