Court Throws Out Grsecurity Libel Lawsuit Against Bruce Perens (reason.com) 48
Long-time Slashdot reader SlaveToTheGrind writes: As previously discussed on Slashdot, Grsecurity developer Open Source Security sued Bruce Perens for allegedly defamatory statements about Grsecurity's licensing policies. Thursday, Magistrate Judge Laurel Beeler of the District Court for the Northern District of California dismissed the lawsuit, holding that Perens's statements were not libelous:
"Mr. Perens counters, and the court agrees, that the blog posts are opinions about a disputed legal issue, are not false assertions of fact, and thus are not actionable libel. . . . Mr. Perens -- who is not a lawyer — voiced an opinion about whether the Grsecurity Access Agreement violated the General Public License. No court has addressed the legal issue. Thus, his "opinion" is not a "fact" that can be proven provably false and thus is not actionable as defamation."
While Open Source Security technically has the ability to amend its complaint to allege a new legal theory, Judge Beeler said any amendment likely would fall under California's anti-SLAPP statute: "Mr. Perens's statements were made in a public forum and concern issues of public interest, and the plaintiffs have not shown a probability of prevailing on their claims."
"Mr. Perens counters, and the court agrees, that the blog posts are opinions about a disputed legal issue, are not false assertions of fact, and thus are not actionable libel. . . . Mr. Perens -- who is not a lawyer — voiced an opinion about whether the Grsecurity Access Agreement violated the General Public License. No court has addressed the legal issue. Thus, his "opinion" is not a "fact" that can be proven provably false and thus is not actionable as defamation."
While Open Source Security technically has the ability to amend its complaint to allege a new legal theory, Judge Beeler said any amendment likely would fall under California's anti-SLAPP statute: "Mr. Perens's statements were made in a public forum and concern issues of public interest, and the plaintiffs have not shown a probability of prevailing on their claims."
Costs to Bruce Perens ? (Score:1)
And how much money and time has the poor guy had to spend to get this judgement ?
Who is Bruce Perens? (Score:1)
Who is Bruce Perens?
Re: Who is Bruce Perens? (Score:1)
He works for the CIA as a North Korean agent who the KGB thinks defected and then used to spy on the Brits. MI6 thinks he is a lost American tourist that can not seem to find his way out of their building.
On a side note, I hope he never goes to NK... this post might get him in a lot of trouble.
Side side note, queue all the govt AI systems that read this post and elevate his security clearance because it appears too low.
Re: (Score:1)
The KGB has not existed in 25 years, you flaming MORON.
Re: (Score:2)
The KGB has not existed in 25 years, you flaming MORON.
Not under that name, anyway. I don't think using an outdated initialism (wtf Mozilla, why is that perfectly cromulent word not in the dictionary? Are you new?) qualifies one for MORON status.
Re:Who is Bruce Perens? (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
I will say I would never willingly do business with a company that so easily files false libel lawsuits. Every company I've ever seen that does so is unstable (think, Donald Trump).
Re: (Score:1)
Every day I come to /. looking for a genuine LOL moment. Today I got it from the teh Bruce.
Re: (Score:3)
Just another privileged white male.
There is not a single person who can post to Slashdot who is Not privileged in some way. At least Bruce Perens is making a stand against evil, and injustice, and free speech suppression with his "privilege": Unlike you, anonymous coward, who are just abusing your privilege to try and insult a great man.
Re:Who is Bruce Perens? (Score:4, Funny)
Is this some kind of John Galt meme, or do you not actually know how to use Google?
Re: (Score:2)
Funnily enough I knew who Bruce Perens is but had to bing John Galt.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
You were fortunate in your assignment of college roommate, then.
Re: Who is Bruce Perens? (Score:1)
What is this some kind of special club? That was a seriously stupid comment.
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Who is Bruce Perens?
You see those curved symbols on your keyboard that look like this ( and this )?
He invented those. [wikipedia.org] Without Parens, the LISP programming language would never have come into being, and C++ and Java would look more like COBOL. Not only that, but the entire communication mechanism known as "emoticons" would not exist, so no one would be able to communicate on the internet. Since emoticons lead to emojis, and emojis are required for text messaging, you would not have text messaging without Bruce and his parens.
Re: (Score:2)
I went to school in England, they told us that they were invented by Hinge & Bracket.
Welcome to Slashdot (Score:2)
Who is Bruce Perens?
You are definitely new here.
Re: (Score:2)
I've been reading Slashdot since 98 and I have no idea who "Bruce Parens" is either.
You are lying about one of those things. Either you haven't actually been reading Slashdot, to which Bruce is a frequent contributor and where he is frequently mentioned in stories relating to legal conflicts in the Open Source and Free Software world, or you know who Bruce Perens is. Either way, you're a liar.
Re:Costs to Bruce Perens ? (Score:5, Interesting)
He may well have had attorneys with suitable expertise already on retainer. Even if not, the marketing value of being on the "right" side of a dispute like this could have tremendous promotional value for him, his brand, and his company--the sort of advertising that no amount of money could buy.
I'm not saying that it's fair that Perens was out any time, money, or inconvenience, or that Grsecurity wasn't trying to abuse the system by filing a spurious lawsuit. But this isn't an instance of a lone blogger's David bravely duking it out against all odds against a giant corporate Goliath. Perens definitely has the knowledge, contacts, and resources to effectively respond to this sort of threat, and is almost certainly one of the dumbest possible choices Grsecurity could have made to sue. Of all possible defendants, Perens is among those with the most to gain from successfully defending against this flimsy suit.
Re: (Score:1)
Bruce Perens has had his anti-SLAPP motion dismissed in order to allow the plaintiff one try to amend their complaint. But the court found no fault in Perens anti-SLAPP motion, they just denied it to give the plaintiff time to amend, and the anti-SLAPP was dismissed without prejudice, meaning Perens can file it again whether or not the plaintiff amends their complaint. The court said in their ruling that they were likely to find for Perens. It is hard to see how any change to the complaint could save the ca
A Word from Bruce Perens (Score:5, Informative)
I apologize for not participating in this discussion, but it is obvious legal hygiene not to discuss the suit until it's all over. There are some things I can discuss: Here is the Court Order [perens.com], and I would like to introduce you to my Wonderful Legal Team [perens.com]. Valerie, Stanley, and I are having a good time over the winter break and wish you all happy holidays. Don't worry about me, and I'll explain what costs I have, if any, when this is over.
Re: (Score:2)
Bunch of wankers (Score:1)
I guess Grsecurity is not only violating the GPL, the organization is also run by lying wankers.