UK Police Want DNA of 'Potential Offenders' 578
mrogers writes "British police want to collect DNA samples from children as young as five who 'exhibit behavior indicating they may become criminals in later life'. A spokesman for the Association of Chief Police Officers argued that since some schools already take pupils' fingerprints, the collection and permanent storage of DNA samples was the logical next step. And of course, if anyone argues that branding naughty five-year-olds as lifelong criminals will stigmatize them, the proposed solution will be to take samples from all children."
Parent needs remodding Insightful (Score:0, Informative)
Re:Will someone explain? (Score:2, Informative)
The UK database contains the DNA of people who've been arrested even when then they're later released uncharged or acquitted.
It is almost impossible to get your record deleted when you are acquitted in England and Wales (but not in Scotland).
So unless you believe that the police only ever arrest the guilty, perhaps you will begin to understand what's making people jumpy.
Re:And? (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Parent needs remodding Insightful (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Meeting expectations (Score:5, Informative)
Re:And? (Score:2, Informative)
Seriously, if you're going to consider boycotting China over their dismal actions, why not our alleged ally who slips closer to a police state every day?
Re:Fucked up kids? (Score:3, Informative)
This is pretty damn contemporary with 1984, think.
Re:First they came for the ... (Score:5, Informative)
First they collected DNA from sex criminals.
Then they collected DNA from felons.
Then they collected DNA from all criminals.
Then they collected DNA from people who get speeding tickets.
Then they collected DNA from people who drive.
Then they collected DNA from everyone else.
Re:So what? (Score:3, Informative)
When it comes to oppressive ideas in the name of preventing crime (or even better, use the word "terrorism"), two of the three main political parties in the UK are happy to lap up whatever crazy idea ACPO will come up with.
Fortunately, we also have the Lords: it seems bizarre to many people, but many of those in the Lords have no real political agenda, because they're there not as a career choice, but as a product of circumstance; as a result, they're the most unbiased political instrument in the machine, and have turned over many a ridiculous idea that's successfully passed muster in the Commons.
Re:US politics... (Score:3, Informative)
a true story... of how this can go horribly wrong. (Score:1, Informative)
My son is 11. He was punched by a 12 year old girl. He reflexively slapped her on the knee and yelled at her to not hit him. He now has a police record. To be fair the girl also has a police record now too and both children were interviewed by police in a gang violence investigation. I'm told it is routine now for the police to interview and take statements from children when any violence occurs in US schools. Everyone in authority has told me not to make a fuss over this.
My son has now been branded as violent for having made one out burst in response to violence. He has been severely punished for this and will be severely punished for any violent behavior. You'll just have to believe me when I say that he has never done anything like this before.
Should his DNA be profiled? Does this outburst indicate a potential to join a gang? Is this what happens to white children in white schools?
We are entering into a society where every action and every statement will be recorded. Every thing you do will point back to you. I don't think this is racism. I think this is fascism. When I was a boy I was beaten and less happened to the people that beat me than what has happened to my son for asserting himself.