Ads With Your Name On Them 153
eldavojohn writes "The NYTimes is running an interesting blog piece on the answers Microsoft, AOL, Yahoo, & Google gave to the question: Can they show you an ad with your name on it? The results: 'Microsoft says it could use only a person's first name [which it doesn't consider personal information]. AOL and Yahoo could use a full name but only on their sites, not the other sites on which they place ads. Google isn't sure; it probably could, but it doesn't know the names of most of its users.' Now whether or not they would use this information is a different story. AOL has no plans to, Yahoo is open to it, and Microsoft has implemented a technological barrier preventing it (despite behavioral and demographic data being served to the ad companies). Although Google might use name information at some point, they don't now do so; nor do they use behavioral or demographic data."
Mobil card (Score:5, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Mobil card ms are NUTS... (Score:5, Insightful)
Microsoft does not say that your first name is not personal information. Their policy prevents the spread of personally identifiable information, which they define as information which could be used by theirselves or others to connect data (including your first name) to you, the individual. Now, using your first name might be a little dodgy in that you might be the only person in the world with the same first name. But generally speaking, you cannot match a person to their data with only first names.
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
-Tupshin
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Tupshin Harper
Director of Engineering
San Francisco Bay Area
First hit for the first name Tupshin.
Re:Mobil card ms are NUTS... (Score:4, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Mobil card ms are NUTS... (Score:4, Insightful)
Yeah, but it seems like this is the sort of thing that won't be influenced by somebody hearing your last name in a store. I mean, if they're going through your trash, they're probably going to find some piece of mail with your last name on it.
Really?
Really?
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
Maybe give that some thought?
Re:Mobil card ms are NUTS... (Score:4, Funny)
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Overreaction much? One wonders how you manage to step outside your house each day without the protection of your t
Re: (Score:2)
I'm exactly the opposite of the previous caller -- I expect people in service industries to use my last name, not my first name. When they use my first name it bothers me and I correct them.
When a customer service goon on the phone says something like, "Can I call you Mike?" I always say, "No." They usually pause for a couple of seconds because their script doesn't have a "No" scenario. Eventually they ask, "Then
Re: (Score:2)
You, uh, don't give them your real name, do you? There is only one store I have a shopper's card for, and it is with a fake name. Although, once when my mother was visiting, I had to tell her ahead of time so she wouldn't look at me funny when the cashier said "Thank you, Mr. Burdell!"
Re: (Score:2)
It makes no difference to stalking though. The *huge* majority of stalkers already know the precise name of the target, simply because the typical stalker is either an ex-friend, ex-boyfriend, ex-girlfriend or other person you know, or alternatively someone stalking a public figure.
It's fairly rare that some random person suddenly starts stalking a random person
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
I disagree. I'd say that the "k" in America is much more likely to be put there by someone who isn't really concerned-- or able-- to violate privacy by culling personal information. Look at their lack of data accuracy, for instance. Anyone with any sort of purpose, be it nefarious or otherwise, would at least be able to spell-check their way through "America". Do you think these type of people could even pronounce your name correctly?
Blurting names also confirms the na
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
If you actually did have a stalker, they will find your name out pretty quickly.
Have you ever had a stalker? Do you know anyone who did? I was under the impression that non-celebrities were sta
Re: (Score:2)
Amazon has already done this... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
Re:Amazon has already done this... (Score:5, Funny)
"Meet sexy singles in [your town]." And then it shows some "example" profiles of some women who are most likely just models. Then I look closer and I think "Oh my God, I've slept with these women! How did they know?" Then I realized that they just got my location from my IP and that I've slept with pretty much all the attractive women around here so it didn't really matter which ones they chose.
Good news is that it reminded me to go get tested for STDs.
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
I get a certain perverted kind of pleasure from that!
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Talk about a different country.
The bank i used to work for, had its router in Hongkong.
It was really fun to watch ads by google in native chinese (mandarin) talking about a concert, etc.
It was more fun to watch yahoo trying the same and giving me a good laugh.
It worked for a while until i tried news.google.com and got redirected to HK news website.
Re: (Score:2)
In Hong Kong the "native" language is Cantonese.
I live there, and am amused sometimes by the sleazy dating ads that show underdressed blonde bimbos under text like "Girls in To Kwa Wan who want to f***".
Re: (Score:2)
No wonder an IT support guy from hongkong called me to question my browsing habits...
And my teacher was right: I should have learnt a second language...
Re: (Score:2)
Well, yes. But I also get lots of ads in English -- my point was that there are not a lot of blonde bimbos in Hong Kong, and it's painfully obvious few if any of the "girls near you" are on the same continent.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
First time I saw "personals" ads on a web page that seemed to know what city I lived in, I kinda freaked.
"Meet sexy singles in [your town]." And then it shows some "example" profiles of some women who are most likely just models. Then I look closer and I think "Oh my God, I've slept with these women! How did they know?" Then I realized that they just got my location from my IP and that I've slept with pretty much all the slutty women around here so it didn't really matter which ones they chose.
Good news is that it reminded me to go get tested for STDs.
There, fixed that for ya.
Re: (Score:2)
That's the funny thing: the few times I'm browsing without AdBlock, I see those ads, and I ask myself "Why would I want to meet sexy singles that live over an hour away from me?" I'm sorry, fly-by-night singles service, but no sex is worth spending that much time on I-4 just to get it.
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
Anyway, while it freaked me out too the first (and still kind of does) it's not like they know anything that any other retailer with cookies doesn't know. It seems like unnecessarily off-putting advertising though.
Re: (Score:2)
Now the big catch with this is, it shifts it from being a passive add to more like being a door to door salesperson, someone that specifically invades your personal private space, which is of course why you react to it as being invasive. So if you have a positive relationship already established with the company
Sounds scary (Score:5, Insightful)
Showing it would just be disclosing our already existing vulnerability.
Re:Sounds scary (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Sounds scary (Score:5, Interesting)
They stopped. I asked why, and they said it really creeped their customers out.
Re:Sounds scary (Score:4, Informative)
Not that if someone broke into my home or faked the CLID to order pizza wouldn't know my name, or that they'd even care. But leave the opportunity for a stupid criminal to be stupid:
"Rule One in housebreaking," said a voice. "Never answer the telephone when you're in the middle of a job. Who are you supposed to be, for heaven's sake?"
Richard froze. It was a moment or two before he could find where he had put his voice.
"Who is this?" he demanded at last in a whisper.
"Rule Two," continued the voice. "Preparation. Bring the right tools. Bring gloves. Try to have the faintest glimmering of an idea of what you're about before you start dangling from window ledges in the middle of the night.
"Rule Three. Never forget Rule Two."
"Who is this?" exclaimed Richard again.
The voice was unperturbed. "Neighborhood Watch," it said. "If you just look out of the back window you'll see..."
Trailing the phone, Richard hurried over to the window and looked out. A distant flash startled him.
"Rule Four. Never stand where you can be photographed.
"Rule Five... Are you listening to me, MacDuff?"
"What? Yes..." said Richard in bewilderment. "How do you know me?"
"Rule Five. Never admit to your name."
Richard stood silent, breathing hard.
"I run a little course," said the voice, "if you're interested..."
Richard said nothing.
"You're learning," continued the voice, "slowly, but you're learning. If you were learning fast you would have put the phone down by now, of course. But you're curious - and incompetent - and so you don't. I don't run a course for novice burglars as it happens, tempting though the idea is. I'm sure there would be grants available. If we have to have them they may as well be trained.
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
Free karma from Google!
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
If the advertiser reveals how well he knows me, he's making me uncomfortable. It's like some stranger knocking on your door an inquiring about the health of your child. It sounds like a threat, or at least establishes an asymmetric relationship (they know more about you than you do about them).
Coming Soon ... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:1, Insightful)
I know I'm new here, but can someone explain how a comment about the Google / Doubleclick merger could possibly be offtopic, when the topic is about whether Google (and others) would serve ads with your personal details on them ???
As for troll ? Erm, well
Do you just get a handful of mod points and play pin the tail on the donkey with them ?
Re: (Score:2)
That's the best overview of slashdot's moderation system that I've seen in a while. Taco should update the faqs with it.
Cheers (Score:4, Insightful)
B. Google certainly can show me my name in the ad. Certainly it knows which gmail account I use, and the name on that. It also knows what billing name I used for my Google Checkout purchases. Similar ways of identifying users apply to the other companies. What worries me, is seeing my name on an ad served by somebody I did NOT share my name with.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It's the end of an era! (Score:3, Funny)
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
Attention, Kdawson (Score:1, Funny)
We have an offer you simply cannot refuse! Kdawson, if you will just submit your name to us, we can use your real name in our ads instead of this silly Slashdot nick for just a one-time fee of $59.95! Get our your checkbook or credit card and call or visit our website today!
Huh? (Score:2)
Where everybody knows your $name (Score:2, Redundant)
The computer doesn't know your name. It echoes a variable.
Re: (Score:2)
(Hey, a lot of people were dumb, 15, and on the Internet once. Don't look so smug.)
Urg, no thanks. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Shot in the dark (Score:2)
Worth a try.
John Smith: This is a message directed for you, and only you. Yes -you-, John Smith. Buy my snake oil! It cures everything, even *that* special problem. Only $99.
Not quite "Minority Report" (Score:2)
ads with your name on them (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Excellent vector for phishing, perhaps. Great way to devalue a person's name; almost assuredly. Great opportunity to figure out which sites are handing over my person all information; definitely.
If this sort of thing does happen, I'm going to start using a different handle for each site that I join, and then refuse to do business with whichever sites are providing my information to the sort of sleaze that would use my personal information to address me via
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
Really? Most people I know just select one for free. Your friends must have more money than mine...
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
Minority Report Please dear god NOOOOOO (Score:3, Funny)
Roflmao
Ben Dover, You May Have Already Won! (Score:2)
Screw them... (Score:4, Insightful)
I do however, care about those people who are less technologically capable, and less privacy conscious being tricked into clicking on ads because they think it is from a friend or whatever (when reading emails especially).
Just because I rarely give out my real name on the web, doesn't mean that there are people who use their real name for everything and don't mind giving it to everyone.
And that's the problem. This won't matter for most people on Slashdot, but it will matter to at least minority of people. And the people with knowledge should promote that knowledge, we should fight against this sort of thing.
(Actually, I suspect that there are a number of people who would get rather angry being addressed by their name when looking at ads. Imagine your TV saying "Hey Joe, I've got a great new beer for you to taste!" or "Hey Joe, I've got a great new computer bit", most people I know would get angry at that. Meh, now I'm starting to ramble.)
I work for an ad agency. (Score:4, Interesting)
And I've written text-based ads for Google, MSN, Yahoo, etc.
But I can't imagine anyone would want to purchase a product based on an ad with their name on it. "Hey Morley! Buy some laundry detergent!" I'd get freaked out, and I'd forever associate that creepy feeling with the product. And I'd never buy it.
I imagine most people would feel the same way. And I imagine most copywriters -- who are less like the oily marketeers you're thinking of -- would feel the same.
I say, if some oily marketeer wants to use this feature -- and it is only at most my first name -- he deserves to scare off his customers.
Newest targeted ad (Score:2)
Snail Mail does it all the time. (Score:4, Informative)
One time on the news site forum I frequent they did that. The news posting/headline used a little trick to display who you were logged in as. Everyone assumed that the story was actually about them. The forums were chaos until everyone figured it out, and through-out the day new people would hurriedly make a comment and then get modded 'redundant' by everyone else.
Even though it was a simple echo of your login-name and not some great technical trick, it was effective enough to give everyone a bit of a startle.
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
"Act now! You could get a check made out to C. today!"
Re: (Score:2)
I personally liked "Rudy Fleminger: NEVER EAT THIS!", but those tapered off pretty quickly.
Re: (Score:2)
I love those becasue my first name is legally C. (it's a long story). I love getting junk mail addressed to C.
I've had a few customers with legal first names that are only a single letter and I'm curious to know what's the story behind that? I have a suspicion, but I'd like to hear it more direct before I open my fool mouth. :)
I was passed a file for a customer whose legal first name was 'T' and there was a bit of awkwardness in the beginning because I didn't quite know what to call her and Mrs. Long Last Name I'd Probably Mispronounce didn't seem appropriate.
"Act now! You could get a check made out to C. today!"
Ugh. I don't have such a first name but those mail
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Wait, I'm adblocking those ads... (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
THIS
IS
DOUBLECLICK!!!
(ducks)
What no "minorityreport" tags? (Score:3, Interesting)
Well, they know your ISP (Score:4, Interesting)
And yes, it makes a difference, these ads are HORRIBEL and anyone with a brain will know that they are ALL scams, how come there are only attractive women near you?
But the naming of your home town makes it seems more legit. It is afterall how confidence tricksters work, by finding stuff out that you somehow let them know but using it in the right way to make you believe they really know you.
Sure! (Score:2)
We take our names seriously here at the Desperation compound. Why just the other day my brothers, Utter and Six-Degrees-Of, were talking about hunting down some of those there mappers for using their email addresses. But then they had to chase away from revenooers and got all distracted like.
MSN Explorer (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Hell freezes over (Score:2)
Poor Nick-Names (Score:1)
what are these ads you speak of? (Score:3, Funny)
Sheldon
Re: (Score:2)
Re:what are these ads you speak of? (Score:4, Funny)
Os this an ad for AOL? (Score:2)
Where are they pulling the info from? (Score:2)
"Type your full name and press enter"
OK...y-o-u-r...f-u-l-l...n-a-m-e...
The Evil Scale as an economic indicator (Score:3, Insightful)
1 (Least Evil): Microsoft (implements tech. barriers)
2 : AOL (no barriers, no plans)
3 : Yahoo (no barriers, shows interest)
4 (Most Evil): Google (no barriers, no comment, lots of extra available data)
If we assume that companies think Evil is a negative for business, this suggests that Google and Yahoo are getting complacent, while Microsoft is working pretty hard again to woo customers and improve its market position.
As usual, spam is way ahead (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
http://xkcd.com/327/ [xkcd.com]
John;')DROP DATABASE users;--Culturally insensitive? Methinks yes... (Score:2)
"You Can't" (Score:4, Funny)
"You Can't find everything you need at carpet warehouse!"
"You Can't find 'quadratic equation' and anything else on eBay!"
I hate those eBay ads that just take your google search input to serve in the ad. Apparently eBay will sell you entire cities.
-b
Adbusters (Score:2)
http://www.dianefarrisgallery.com/artist/woods/ex00/images/02.jpg [dianefarrisgallery.com]
Google knows your name (Score:3, Interesting)
They know countless random topics that have popped into my head, because the first thing I do is to Google them. This has taught them all sorts of things about my personality and interests, including topics I might keep private from most everyone I know. When I go to Google News they learn about what events catch my attention. They know I still only click on a Google Ad every few months, but that hasn't stopped them from showing ads every chance they get. And of course, they've got Doubleclick now just on the off chance that I might be visiting a site they don't cover or that I might click on an ad they didn't provide.
I didn't even mention Picasa or Google Earth. And if that's not enough, just imagine what they'll know once they get a piece of the internet backbone.
No offense to the Googlebot reading this!
weasels (Score:2)
They ask for your name when you register, so if they can tie your account to an ad, they can tie your name to any ad. Of course, people who sign up may simply not be giving their correct name, but that's not due to any Google privacy policy.
Microsoft says it could use only a person's first name. AOL and Yahoo could use a full name but only on their sites,
That's bullshit. Like Google, they ask the user for their full nam
Re: (Score:2)