Forgot your password?

typodupeerror
Government Privacy United Kingdom Your Rights Online

Powerline Networks Interfere With Spooks? 85

Posted by CmdrTaco
from the i'm-ok-with-that dept.
An anonymous reader writes "Powerline technology which ships network data over mains cables could be causing interference for spies, according to a letter from the UK's top secret listening station, GCHQ. However, the British regulator says that objections to powerline all come from radio amateurs — and a Google search reveals that the writer of the letter (which GCHQ seems to be disowning) comes from a ham."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Powerline Networks Interfere With Spooks?

Comments Filter:
  • Violation of treaty (Score:5, Interesting)

    by Caerdwyn (829058) on Tuesday May 17 2011, @02:04PM (#36156598) Journal

    There are international treaties concerning radio interference. Among the provisions of these treaties are sections defining amateur radio frequencies which are not to be assigned to other usage or interfered with. If power line communications interferes with amateur radio and emergency radio services [nato.int], the country in question is in noncompliance with the treaties involved. The governing body of these treaties is the International Telecommunications Union [itu.int]; the United States and the United Kingdom are both signatories. (actually, almost every country on Earth is, with the non-signatories being North Korea and their ilk)

    In the United States at least, treaties come immediately after the Constitution in being the highest law of the land (the Supremacy Clause). Depending upon where you are, your kilometerage may vary.

  • Strange Story (Score:4, Interesting)

    by locallyunscene (1000523) on Tuesday May 17 2011, @02:16PM (#36156810)
    So GCHQ’s spectrum manager wrote this letter on official letterhead in March and somehow released or leaked it. The GCHQ claims it was not an official document, and insinuates as a ham operator the spectrum manager was trying to further his own hobby's agenda. The UK ham operators lobbyist group "Ban Power Line Technology" [ban-plt.co.uk] has a copy of this "unofficial" letter and is using it to prove that this technology is damaging the public good, but nothing is "official". How convenient for the GCHQ.

    Ironically, i could easily see this having the opposite effect that the GCHQ is hoping for. I think more people care about having privacy in their home than inconveniencing ham operators.

Drive defensively. Buy a tank.

Working...