EMI Using Rapidshare To Market Music 81
An anonymous reader writes "While Rapidshare defends itself around the world from lawsuits by media companies for copyright infringement, new evidence was revealed that UK-based major label EMI is putting music on Rapidshare and directing people to download it in the hopes that it spreads 'virally.' This came to light in the ongoing copyright battle EMI v. MP3tunes over personal cloud media storage and the Sideload.com music search engine. EMI accuses MP3tunes of enabling piracy by linking to Rapidshare, but since EMI is using Rapidshare, this would seem to weaken their argument considerably. You can read the legal brief online."
Re:Make up your mind (Score:4, Informative)
That’s a mere technicality... they can’t catch you for downloading. So they can’t sue you for it.
They tried putting honey-pots on P2P networks, serving up fake files with filenames that made them look like copyrighted stuff. Then when people downloaded them, they sued. They lost. No copyright infringement occurred, because no copyrighted material was actually copied.
They tried putting the real files on the P2P honey-pots, then suing people for downloading them. That went even less well, since the people were downloading the files from the copyright holder, which makes it all perfectly okay – even if the people downloading didn’t know it.
They tried downloading their files from people, then suing them for making the copy... but that failed for the same reason. If the copyright holder asks you to make them a copy of their own stuff, you’re authorized to do it. Even if you don’t know they’re the copyright holder.
Finally they claimed that simply making the files available is proof positive that you were infringing on their copyright, based on the way P2P networks work. They can’t prove that you uploaded it to anyone, but they claimed that it was a statistical certainty that you had.
And they still can’t get you for downloading the file. For all they know, you could have downloaded it from a legal MP3 store such as iTunes.