IBM Patents Tweeting Remote Control 282
Fluffeh writes "IBM has applied for a patent on a network-enabled smart remote control that sends out a message to Twitter, Facebook or a blog when you start watching a TV show." Hopefully this launches an exciting patent landgrab of devices that are socially enabled. Your car can tweet when you leave your garage. Your dishwasher can tweet when the load is done. Your skillet can tweet when your eggs are burnt. And they say innovation is dead.
Suppress innovation (Score:5, Insightful)
Hopefully this launches an exciting patent landgrab of devices that are socially enabled.
... or suppresses any such innovation, since there's a prior patent.
Guys, I don't get it (Score:2, Insightful)
Twitter, I mean. I don't understand why it's so popular, am I just getting old?
What's its draw?
Hooray for Patents (Score:3, Insightful)
This patent will prevent most remote-control manufacturers from ever producing a device that does this.
I'm going to go out and patent all kinds of devices being "socially"-enabled. It's the only way to be sure.
Re:Suppress innovation (Score:4, Insightful)
I for one welcome our new "digital DDT" patent overlords!
Re:That's patentable? (Score:3, Insightful)
Nah... prior art. Sort of. Obligatory Penny Arcade Twitter Comic [penny-arcade.com].
Re:Guys, I don't get it (Score:5, Insightful)
There's a lot of twits out there, and they needed their own messaging protocol.
As far as I see it, it doesn't break my leg or steal my car. They can have at it. Just like they had at Second Life and whatever the revolution-of-the-future was before that.
Re:Guys, I don't get it (Score:4, Insightful)
Twitter is just an extension of MyFace & SpaceBook in that it allows you to create an even greater illusion that the mundane and tedious facets of your everyday life are something that thousands, nay millions of people are desperate to read about. So desperate, in fact, that they can't even wait for a daily rundown and must instead know about them within seconds of them occuring.
Now, not only can you pretend that you've got more friends than some random people on the internet, but also that said friends care in the slightest about what you do.
Re:Wow. (Score:2, Insightful)
This whole Twitter phenomenon seems to reinforce the narcissistic personality common in today's 25 or younger crowd. They think 'Everyone will want to know I watched Top Model tonight, and 90210 and Gossip Girl last night.'
Re:Wow. (Score:5, Insightful)
Frankly, I prefer being anonymous for most of the time, until "I" choose to make myself known to my friends. I call it 'getting together with them for drinks....'
Re:Yes! (Score:1, Insightful)
Better than knowing it's filled up before a flush.
Re:Wow. (Score:5, Insightful)
It seems to me that people who regularly tweet about every little thing have some sort of deep-seated need for constant validation from the outside world. They post personal details in order to evoke some kind of response just to show that someone, somewhere is paying attention to them. I find that sort of mentality kind of sad, but apparently it's a lot more common than I would have thought.
Re:this should be easy (Score:5, Insightful)
The primary reason why the patent shouldn't be granted is it's a minor variation on existing ideas that takes no real effort to dream up or create. A 10 minute brain storming session could come up with dozens of ideas of equivalent value. Also, a prototype of the device could probably be created in minutes using a computer or smartphone with an IR port. Or look at a custom pvr setup.
This is hardly a patent protecting any real R&D. This is like patenting different configurations of three blocks of Lego. Oh yes, my patent is original! The top block is shifted one peg farther to the right! It's a completely new design!
Re:Wow. (Score:3, Insightful)
Using twitter to communicate friends who live the same place as you do is somewhat redundant and stupid, yes.
But I use it and related services to stay in touch with several friends who do not live close by and who do not know every detail of my life anyway. This enables me to stay close to these people even if we only see each other a couple of times a year. I find it very useful. But then again, I don't (usually) post silly stuff like when I'm eating or watching TV or stuff. But if I'm going out with some other people, go to watch a movie, acquire a new gadget that is just too cool and stuff like that, I may post a short notice about it.
Twitter messages are easy to ignore if you don't care about them, don't take up much of your time, yet allow you to stay updated with your friends when geography would make it difficult otherwise.
They remind me of little children... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:this should be easy (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:this should be easy (Score:3, Insightful)
How easy it is to build a prototype really doesn't matter.
What does matter is whether the approach is novel. A novel approach can be very easy to implement once you have the key insight, and reaching that insight (not constructing a prototype) is the work that earns patent protection.
My problem with this patent is this: I don't think you can state a problem to which this is a novel soltuion. The reason this hasn't been done isn't that nobody could figure out how - it's that nobody cared. If somebody had said "I want to do X", what aspect of the patented invention wouldn't have been an obvious part of the solution?
This patent covers a solution looking for a problem. In a certain demographic, it may carry a certain "cool" factor that allows it to catch on. "Hey, cool, I hadn't thought to do what this invention does." But that's not what patents are for.
Don't get me wrong - it's possible to have a "solution looking for a problem" that is novel and merits a patent. In those cases, when someone hears about the invention they would say "hey, cool; I hadn't thought of it, but I'd like to do that... however, I can't say I understand how you did it".
Re:Wow. (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Wow. (Score:2, Insightful)
Dear Twitter User... (Score:2, Insightful)
Your television in your living room is a 52" plasma?! Awesome! I'll be over shortly to take it as well as any other valuables you constantly blab about on your twitter account. You make it so much easier for me to do my job. Thank you ever so much!
-Your Neighborhood Nice Guy
Re:Guys, I don't get it (Score:2, Insightful)
Yes, but they wait until Friday night to plan Friday night. My wife and I had some friends (younger) who did the whole "instant communications" last-minute planning thing using cell phones... we almost always had to tell them "sorry, can't make it, we already have plans." We figured out in advance what we were going to do Friday night and were already doing it. The instant communications enables last-minute "planning", but is that really a good thing overall for socialization? (That's a real question from me to whoever, by the way.)
I've never even thought of using Twitter because I'm too busy doing things to be sending little infomercials about what I'm doing. Maybe its because I'm old... but maybe its because I'm old enough to not need the constant hand-holding that some folks seem to need, whether by cell phone or by Twitter.
Are we evolving into a society requiring constant validation of our place in the society? Are we becoming that insecure? Or are we evolving into some kind of geographically-disperse human-herd animal now that we have the enabling technology?