Forgot your password?

typodupeerror
Privacy Education Government The Courts United States News

Middle-School Strip Search Ruled Unconstitutional 528

Posted by timothy
from the moment-of-claritin dept.
yuna49 writes "The US Supreme Court today ruled 8-1 that the strip search of a 13-year-old girl by officials in an Arizona middle school was unconstitutional. However, by a vote of 7-2, the Court also ruled that the individual school officials could not be held personally liable. A suit for damages against the school district itself is still going forward. We discussed this case at length back in March when the Court decided to hear the case on appeal."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Middle-School Strip Search Ruled Unconstitutional

Comments Filter:
  • by calmofthestorm (1344385) on Thursday June 25 2009, @04:43PM (#28471903)

    Good point, it's interstate commerce!

  • Re:Well... (Score:3, Funny)

    by cervo (626632) on Thursday June 25 2009, @04:46PM (#28471953) Journal
    You'll get used to it by the time you hit 20 :)
  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday June 25 2009, @04:48PM (#28471993)

    Should we be building more private prisons to hold them cheaply, or should we be cherishing them and making sure they don't see Janet Jackson's nipple?

    The kids can ram it. Join me and my fellow Middle School Deans from across this land as we tell these ungrateful bastards to fuck off. We are applying en masse to the peace corp so we can assist more grateful African children.

    Besides, has anyone ever considered that with a little government money to train my brothers and I in basic medical screening techniques we could be years more advanced in the level of health care delivered to our young people. Decades of pre-teen co-ed athletes have marched through the shower room of my Middle School - that is *DECADES* of young women I could have helped with *MY OWN HANDS* !!

    Think of the children my ass.

  • by MightyMartian (840721) on Thursday June 25 2009, @04:50PM (#28472073) Journal

    The kids can ram it. Join me and my fellow Middle School Deans from across this land as we tell these ungrateful bastards to fuck off. We are applying en masse to the peace corp so we can assist more grateful African children.

    Yes, I guess it will be easier to get a look at girls' chests in countries with flimsy constitutional protections.

    Besides, has anyone ever considered that with a little government money to train my brothers and I in basic medical screening techniques we could be years more advanced in the level of health care delivered to our young people. Decades of pre-teen co-ed athletes have marched through the shower room of my Middle School - that is *DECADES* of young women I could have helped with *MY OWN HANDS* !!

    Yeah, I want you around my kids.

  • by MightyMartian (840721) on Thursday June 25 2009, @04:59PM (#28472221) Journal

    A lot of nerds really like perscription Ibuprofen and are hope they'll be strip searched by hot blonde vixens in uniforms if they use it.

    There, fixed that for ya.

  • by CorporateSuit (1319461) on Thursday June 25 2009, @05:04PM (#28472311)
    Because now we know that we can store torrents and pirated files in children's underpants (aka UnderWarez) that cannot, constitutionally, be searched by their school administrations.
  • by iamhigh (1252742) on Thursday June 25 2009, @05:06PM (#28472367)
    Well, unlike your argument/hypothetical situation, a 13 year old can hold (their) water.
  • by Hognoxious (631665) on Thursday June 25 2009, @05:07PM (#28472385) Homepage Journal
    KIng James Vible?
  • Even in the USSR - which most slashdotters associate with complete absence of civil rights - a strip search of a teen girl by a school official never could have happened.

    I totally agree. Given the transparency and openness of the Soviet system, it's 20 gaziliion trillion percent sure that if it had happened, we'd all know about it.

    And Russia still pwnz everyone at libert[eh|ai|é] and all that shite. I mean, nosy journalists would never be assassinated by agents of the state. And even if they did, there'd never be a rigged trial to let the culprits walk away Scot-free.

    Now some might say that you communidiots are as bad as the libertards, and that it would be a most excellent idea to drop you all in some irrelevant and expendable place like Somalia, Belgium or Detroit and let you slug it out, all on prime time TV. Ignore them; they're capitalist running pig-dogs, all of them, and they'll be first against the wall when the revolution comes.

  • by idontgno (624372) on Thursday June 25 2009, @05:41PM (#28472931) Journal

    "School-issue speculums" just doesn't have a comforting ring about it.

    But does sound AWESOME for the name of a punk rock band.

  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday June 25 2009, @05:57PM (#28473177)

    Dude we live in the cocaine capital of Europe where the government can't make up his mind if possession of a small amount of cannabis should get you an official telling off or just condescending lecture from a uniformed plod. Of course we can't understand why a bunch mad Yanks would think strip searching a 13 year old girl over some Ibuprofen is a good idea. Probably has something to do with socialism or something.

  • by ichbineinneuben (1065378) on Thursday June 25 2009, @06:16PM (#28473393)
    As Justice Stevens said, "it does not require a constitutional scholar to conclude that a nude search of a 13-year-old child is an invasion of constitutional rights of some magnitude." But it took Justice Thomas to get to the heart of it, when he said, "Whadda ya mean, no one took pictures?"
  • by Chris Burke (6130) on Thursday June 25 2009, @06:51PM (#28473875) Homepage

    Rule #1 of parenting is never leave your kids alone with someone until after they agree to tell you their name.

    The police department has the same rule about giving recruits guns.

    Fucking fascists.

  • by HeronBlademaster (1079477) <heron@xnapid.com> on Thursday June 25 2009, @07:17PM (#28474337) Homepage

    We should ban gum. You never know what stuff they're mixing in before they bring it on campus! ~

  • by commodoresloat (172735) * on Thursday June 25 2009, @08:16PM (#28475181)

    as it is now as a parent I would press sex offense charges in both cases, sue the pants off the school district...

    Then you're no better than they are! Two wrongs don't make a right; just because they saw your daughter's unmentionables doesn't mean you get to see theirs...

  • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday June 25 2009, @11:08PM (#28476805)

    you're not getting into my kids underpants unless you're an officer of the law with a warrant in hand

    No interest in being a grandparent whatsoever? Or just want your kids to have interesting fetishes?

  • by XnavxeMiyyep (782119) on Friday June 26 2009, @10:41AM (#28482361)
    No, his copy [nytimes.com] has the Bill of Obligations and Bill of Responsibilities, and he's tired of everyone focusing on civil liberties!

Space is to place as eternity is to time. -- Joseph Joubert

Working...