Berman Retreats, But Only To Regroup

thefinite writes "It looks like the P2P vigilante bill sponsored by Berman is going to have to be rewritten even just to be considered. A ZDNet story talks about the likelihood that the bill will get anywhere as currently written. Hopefully, the second time around will make it clear that the idea is flawed, not just the text."

Regroup to fight terrorists....

[MosesJones]

You can imagine the wording now "Terrorists could use a P2P network to share information, or to co-ordinate attacks."

Same shit different spin. I doubt they'll be watering it down, just making it more of a general threat than being specific on copyright.

This is like...

[MCMLXXVI]

Saying kids are using illeagal fireworks so we are going to use flamethrowers on the kids to disable the fireworks.

Wait for the movie

[Anonymous Coward]

The MPAA and RIAA are creating and marketing a bold, new superhero, The P2P Vigilante

Press relase: "We hope to educate the youth and public of America about the dangers of P2P file sharing- in the fine tradition of propaganda through the ages, the P2P Vigliante, a young, hip, midriff-baring female superhero will deal out justice and vengance to those who would use a P2P network for evil. Which is everyone who uses a P2P network. It's, like, evil and stuff. Anyway, it's on every Tuesday night at 8 (7 Central) on the WB! Excuse me, I have to go do a few lines of coke."

Re:Regroup to fight terrorists....

[the_other_one]

Terrorists could beat out messages on drums and other musical instruments. They could even use this method to co-ordinate attacks.

Music should be banned.

This would also solve all our problems with the RIAA.

The real reason is...

[LordHunter317]

I think the real reason it isn't happening is because Berman learned from here [freedom-to-tinker.com] that his Musical Car horn on his nice shiny Cadallic would be outlawed. The new law will probably be ... "All devices which play digital copyrighted stuff must be regulated, except for my musical car horn."

Hey, Mr. Infringer...

[Eric_Cartman_South_P]

...it's "Terrorists(TM)". Get it right, God(C) damnit!

Re:I'm getting cynical.

[iplayfast]

Even worse. I'm a Canadian, so I am not affected by this stuff....

NOT!

The crappy US legislation always seems to find it's way into Canada sooner or later. Worse I can't even vote the people out who are making this stuff up.

Sometimes it truly is like sleeping next to an Elephant. (with bad gas!)

Re:I'm getting cynical.

[Faggot]

Wow, Man! This Is Totally A Refreshingly Insightful And Insightfully Refreshing Indictment Of The Practices Of Elected Officials In Modern America!

Gag me with a taser.

p.s. iplayfasterthanyou [id-nh.com]

What what what?

[VitrosChemistryAnaly]

When I first read the headline I thought it said "Batman Retreats, But Only To Regroup"

Then I realized that it couldn't be true 'cause Batman never retreats.

Okay now that that's over it's time for me to actually read the article. Check for intelligent post later

Re:I'm getting cynical.

[L. VeGas]

"The crappy US legislation always seems to find it's way into Canada sooner or later."

It's our way of getting even for taking Michael J. Fox.

Re:This is a good thing for everyone

[Waab]

If they're lumping all the White and Black Hat hackers together on the "bad" side, what will the new "good" hackers be called? Coming soon to a movie studio or record label near you ... Green Hat hackers, protecting the bottom line.

Re:What what what?

[BabyDave]

I'd criticise you, but I read the last sentence of the article as

Hopefully, the second time around will make it clear that the idiot is flawed, not just the text."

so who am I to judge?

Re:Regroup to fight terrorists....

[Darth Pondo]

The RIAA has no problem with us buying the music, just listening to it.

Berman retreats

[WalletBoy]

It's about time Berman gets taken to task. Trek has been awful for years under his reign.

Batman!

[ljaguar]

Am I the only who read

Batman Retreats, But Only To Regroup?

"Holy low self-esteem batman! I'm a side kick in my own fantasy!"

Re:What would get passed?

[JordoCrouse]

Since he admits that in its current form there is no way the bill would be passed, what would have to be changed to be passed?

He probably had to take out the part that said "constitution, smonstitution...."

I think it sounds like a lot of fun

[Error27]

A Wild West aproach to internet justice would be great.

Instead of throwing lawsuits around just bring in the programmers and attack the networks with technology. This way if you want to create a network all you need is a few great ideas and some determination... As it is p2p programmers must compete against corporations based on how much they can pay a lawyer.

Unfortunately, I suspect doubt p2p programmers will not be allowed to automate counter attacks against attackers...

So basically the idea is crap until that gets changed.

PS. One idea that's related to this is that we could solve minor disagreements between parties by giant robot battles. This would save millions in tax payer dollars.

Re:Hey, Mr. Infringer...

[Anonymous Coward]

If God is copyrighted, then he should use the DMCA against my boss for passing himself off as a poor quality copy.

Re:I'm getting cynical.

[Anonymous Coward]

I think he's running against some chick, Hilary Rosen I think her name is? I've never heard of her, but she's got my vote then.

Re:That's just standard negotiation

[the_2nd_coming]

ok,

middle ground: in order to copy and distribute anything you want, you have to burn down your house and roast your children over the embers.

One of Canada's finest Shakespearean actors ...

[burgburgburg]

Willian Shatner

What does ...God...need with a starship?

I ...Am ...KIROK!!!!

Khan!!!
Khannnnnn!!!
Khannnnnnnnnn!!!

Re:Regroup to fight terrorists....

[lendude]

with the vigilAnce and alerTness of The averAge /. user, this Could never happen. i Know these hallowed boards shall Never be used as a platfOrm for dissemination of communications With evil intent!