IBM Canada's Position On DMCA

iplayfast writes: "In regards to Canadian "DMCA" Public Comments Becoming Available Most comments look pretty level headed, but as you start moving up the corporate ladder they start looking scary. This is IBM Canada's response "IBM urges the Government to amend the Copyright Act to create a civil and criminal offence for tampering with copyright protection technology systems including a product, service, device, component, or technology - either hardware, software or both - and only part thereof. This offence must have an intent component which should arise from evidence of any one of the following three criteria; -the device has been primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing; or -it has only limited commercial purpose or use other than to circumvent; or -it is marketed by the person who manufactures it, imports it, offers it to the public, provides it or otherwise traffics in it with intent for use in circumventing.; If the person above does this indirectly through another party, both should be culpable." Hmm, Big Blue is showing his spots."

This IBM response is quite lengthy, and worth reading. Besides the statement excerpted here, it includes among other things an argument against mandating particular technological means to combat copyright violations, and acknowledgement that copy-capable equipment is widely available and useful in business and personal contexts. Well ... if you're copying floppies, anyway.

Re:I really want to like IBM...

[lie as cliche]

It's a pity that there's no fundamental separation of Corp and State.

We've corps insisting that the government needs to stay out of their affairs, and then demanding that said government legislate in their favor. And in the U.S. we usually find them succeeding on both fronts.